
The Short Version for an Agency Owner
Pick Trello if your agency is under ten people and lives in boards, and pick Basecamp once a flat fee beats paying per seat. Trello Standard costs $5 per user per month billed annually, so a six-person agency pays $360 a year, as of October 2026. Basecamp Pro costs a flat $79 a month for up to 10 users, which is $948 a year, but it bundles chat, docs, schedules and client access that Trello does not have. The crossover is not about features so much as how many client projects you keep open at once, because Basecamp caps active projects and Trello caps file size and automation instead.
The rest of this guide walks through both billing models, what each cap means for client work, and a worked example for an eight-person shop. Confirm current pricing on the official site before you commit, because both vendors change plans more often than they change logos.
Why Agencies Keep Asking This Question
A small agency has a problem that most product teams do not. Every client is a separate project with its own deadlines, files and people, and some of those people are outside the company.
That makes the tool choice a billing question as much as a workflow question. A per-seat tool punishes you for inviting a client or a freelancer, while a flat-fee tool punishes you for keeping too many projects open. Basecamp and Trello sit at opposite ends of that trade, which is why they get compared so often.
What Basecamp Charges and What You Get
Basecamp sells one product with a flat price and no per-user fees on any paid plan, as its pricing page states. The free Personal plan allows 3 users, 1 active project and 1 GB of storage.
The paid ladder climbs by active projects and users. Freelancer costs $29 a month for up to 5 users, 3 active projects and 10 GB. Pro costs $79 a month for up to 10 users, 8 active projects and 25 GB, and Pro Plus costs $99 a month for up to 15 users, 12 active projects and 100 GB.
Pro Unlimited removes every cap. It costs $199 a month billed annually or $329 a month billed monthly, includes 1 TB of storage, and extra storage runs $50 a month per additional 1 TB. Every paid plan comes with a 30-day free trial, and registered 501(c)(3) nonprofits get 10% off, as of October 2026.
Archived and deleted projects do not count against the active project cap. For an agency that means closing out finished engagements is not housekeeping, it is budget management.
What Trello Charges and Where the Limits Sit
Trello bills per user per month and its pricing page lists four tiers. The Free plan covers up to 10 collaborators per Workspace, up to 10 boards, unlimited Power-Ups per board, 10 MB per file upload and 250 Workspace command runs a month.
Standard costs $5 per user per month billed annually or $6 billed monthly. It lifts the board cap, raises file uploads to 250 MB and allows 1,000 Workspace command runs a month. Premium costs $10 per user per month billed annually or $12.50 billed monthly, with unlimited command runs and the calendar, timeline and dashboard views that make it a real project tool.
Enterprise costs $17.50 per user per month billed annually, which the page states as $210 per user per year. It adds unlimited Workspaces and Atlassian Guard Standard, and it is well past what a small agency needs. Downgrading from a paid plan leaves a free Workspace limited to 10 boards again.
The Two Billing Models Side by Side
- ● Basecamp is a flat fee from $29 a month
- ● Trello is $5 to $12.50 per user per month
- ● Basecamp caps active projects, Trello caps nothing on paid tiers
The table below puts the two ladders next to each other for the plans a small agency would realistically consider. Prices are as of October 2026 and taken from the vendor pages linked above.
| What you are paying for | Basecamp | Trello |
|---|---|---|
| Billing unit | Flat fee per account | Per user per month |
| Free tier | 3 users, 1 project, 1 GB | 10 collaborators, 10 boards, 10 MB files |
| Entry paid plan | Freelancer $29 a month, 5 users, 3 projects | Standard $5 per user a month annual |
| Mid plan | Pro $79 a month, 10 users, 8 projects | Premium $10 per user a month annual |
| Upper plan | Pro Plus $99 a month, 15 users, 12 projects | Enterprise $17.50 per user a month annual |
| No-cap plan | Pro Unlimited $199 a month annual | Premium has unlimited boards and runs |
| What the cap counts | Active projects and users | Seats, file size, command runs |
| Storage | 10 GB to 1 TB by plan | 10 MB or 250 MB per file, no total stated |
| Trial | 30 days on paid plans | Premium trial, length not stated |
| Built-in chat and docs | Yes | No, cards and comments only |
The shape of the two columns is the whole story. Basecamp gets more expensive when you add clients, and Trello gets more expensive when you add people.
Active Projects Versus Boards
Basecamp counts active projects, and for an agency a project almost always maps to one client engagement. A retainer client, a one-off website build and an internal marketing project are three active projects, so a four-person studio with five clients already needs Pro, not Freelancer.
Trello does not cap boards on any paid plan. You can keep one board per client, one per campaign and one per sprint, and the bill does not move. What moves the bill is inviting a freelancer or a client as a Workspace member, because each one is a seat.
Trello has a partial escape hatch. The Standard plan lists single board guests, so a client who only needs one board does not have to become a paid member. A guest on more than one board is billed at the member rate. Basecamp is stricter than people expect: its pricing FAQ says every person you add is counted toward the user limit, clients included, and only Pro Unlimited lifts that cap.
Storage, Files and Automation Caps
File size matters more for agencies than for most teams because design files are large. Trello Free caps uploads at 10 MB, which is smaller than a single print-ready PDF, and Standard raises that to 250 MB per file.
Basecamp caps total storage rather than file size. Freelancer gives 10 GB, Pro gives 25 GB, Pro Plus gives 100 GB and Pro Unlimited gives 1 TB with $50 a month per extra terabyte. An agency that stores final deliverables in Dropbox or Google Drive will rarely hit those numbers, but one that uploads every revision will.
Automation is the other quiet cap. Trello Free allows 250 Workspace command runs a month and Standard allows 1,000, so a board that moves cards automatically on every due date can run out mid-month. Premium removes the limit. Basecamp has no comparable automation engine, which is either a relief or a deal-breaker depending on how you work.
An Eight-Person Agency With Twelve Clients
- ● Trello Premium costs $960 a year for eight
- ● Basecamp Pro Plus costs $1,188 a year flat
- ● The gap closes as the team grows past ten
Take an agency with eight staff, twelve active client projects and a habit of inviting two freelancers at any time. Here is what each tool costs for a year, using the October 2026 list prices and rounding only at the end.
On Trello, eight staff plus two freelancers is ten seats. Standard billed annually is $5 times 10 times 12 months, which is $600 a year. Premium billed annually is $10 times 10 times 12, which is $1,200 a year, and the monthly billing versions come to $720 and $1,500.
On Basecamp, twelve active projects rules out Pro, which stops at 8, so the floor is Pro Plus at $99 a month for up to 15 users. That is $1,188 a year flat, and the two freelancers fit inside the 15-user cap. Every client contact you invite counts too, so inviting one person per client would push you to 22 users. Pro Unlimited at $199 a month billed annually would be $2,388 a year.
| Option | Monthly figure | Annual total |
|---|---|---|
| Trello Standard, 10 seats, annual | $5 x 10 | $600 |
| Trello Premium, 10 seats, annual | $10 x 10 | $1,200 |
| Trello Premium, 10 seats, monthly billing | $12.50 x 10 | $1,500 |
| Basecamp Pro Plus, flat | $99 | $1,188 |
| Basecamp Pro Unlimited, annual | $199 | $2,388 |
The example shows that Basecamp Pro Plus and Trello Premium land within $12 of each other for this agency. The decision then turns on whether you want chat and docs inside the tool or a board engine with automation and views. Our SaaS pricing calculator lets you re-run the sum with your own headcount and client count.
The Point Where Basecamp Gets Cheaper
Because Trello is per seat and Basecamp is flat, there is always a headcount where the lines cross. On Trello Premium annual the cost is $120 per person per year. Basecamp Pro at $948 a year is cheaper once you pass 7 people, and Pro Plus at $1,188 wins once you pass 9.
Against Trello Standard the crossover sits much higher. Standard annual is $60 per person per year, so you need 16 people before Basecamp Pro is cheaper, and by then Basecamp Pro only allows 10 users anyway. In practice Basecamp only beats Trello Standard on price if you would otherwise need Premium features.
The project cap complicates the math from the other side. Twelve clients on Pro Plus is fine, but twenty clients means Pro Unlimited at $2,388 a year, which Trello never asks for. Count your open engagements before you count your people.
What Each Tool Does That the Other Cannot
Basecamp is a bundle. Its pricing page lists Message Boards, To-dos, Scheduling, Docs and Files, and Campfires and Pings as core features on every package, so a small agency can retire Slack and a wiki at the same time. That bundle is why its flat fee is worth more than the dollar comparison suggests.
Trello is a board. It does one thing with cards and lists and relies on Power-Ups for everything else, which the page says number more than 200. Premium adds calendar, timeline, table and dashboard views, so the board can show a client timeline without leaving the tool. If your agency already runs on Slack and Google Drive, Trello slots in without replacing anything.
Neither tool is a time tracker or an invoicing system. If billing by the hour is central to your agency, read our guide on built-in time tracking vs a separate app before you assume either tool will cover it.
Which Tool Fits Your Agency
- ● Under five people and three clients means Basecamp Freelancer
- ● Boards per client with freelancers means Trello Standard
- ● Fifteen people and twelve retainers means Basecamp Pro Plus
Two founders and three clients: Basecamp Freelancer at $29 a month covers 5 users and 3 active projects, and the bundled chat means no second tool. Trello Free also works if you can live with 10 MB uploads.
Six people, boards for everything, freelancers come and go: Trello Standard at $5 per user billed annually. Seats can be added and removed monthly, and unlimited boards mean every client gets their own without a cap conversation.
Eight to fifteen people with a dozen retainers: Basecamp Pro Plus at $99 a month flat. The project cap of 12 fits, the user cap of 15 leaves room, and the price is roughly level with Trello Premium while including more.
A studio that wants timelines and dashboards for client reporting: Trello Premium at $10 per user billed annually. The views and unlimited automation are the point, and a team under eight stays below the Basecamp Pro price.
Twenty clients and growing: Count projects first. Basecamp means Pro Unlimited at $199 a month annual, while Trello Premium for ten people is half that, so Trello wins on price unless you need the bundle.
Run Both With One Real Client Before You Decide
The cheapest test is a real project, not a demo. Put one current client into Basecamp on the 30-day trial and the same client into a Trello Premium trial, and let the team pick the one they stop complaining about.
While you test, watch two numbers. In Trello, check the command run counter and the file size of your typical upload, and in Basecamp, count how many projects you would need to archive each month to stay under the cap. Those two numbers will settle the choice before any feature list does.
Whatever you pick, confirm current pricing on the official site when you sign up, since both pages above have changed within the past year. The right tool for a small agency is the one whose cap you will never notice.
If Trello is already the front-runner, the next question is whether the free tier can carry the agency for a while. Our guide on whether Trello Free is enough for a small team maps the 10-collaborator and 10-board caps against what Standard adds for $5 a seat.
Agencies that want client timelines will soon weigh Premium against Standard. Our comparison of Trello Standard and Premium for a small team shows when the views and unlimited automation earn the extra $5 a seat.
FAQ
Is Basecamp cheaper than Trello for a small agency?
Basecamp charges a flat monthly fee per account, so adding a tenth person costs nothing as long as the plan allows that many users. Trello charges per user, so every seat adds $5 to $12.50 a month depending on the plan and billing cycle, as of October 2026.
Can a small agency run on the Trello or Basecamp free plan?
Yes, within limits. Trello lists its Free plan for up to 10 collaborators per Workspace with 10 boards, 10 MB file uploads and 250 Workspace command runs a month. Basecamp Personal is free for 3 users, 1 project and 1 GB of storage.
What does the Basecamp active project limit mean for client work?
Active projects are the ones you have not archived, and Basecamp caps them on the paid tiers below Pro Unlimited. Freelancer allows 3, Pro allows 8 and Pro Plus allows 12. Archived or deleted projects do not count, so closing finished client work keeps you under the cap.
Does Trello charge extra for Power-Ups?
Trello says every plan can add unlimited Power-Ups per board, and the catalog lists more than 200 apps and tools. Some partner Power-Ups charge their own fees on top of the Trello subscription, so budget for those separately.
Which tool has the longer free trial, Basecamp or Trello?
Basecamp lists a 30-day free trial on its paid plans. Trello offers a Premium trial from the Free plan but does not state how long it lasts on the pricing page. Both let you start without a card, so testing them with one real client project is cheap.
Sources
- Basecamp Pricing — checked 2026-10-27
- Trello Pricing — checked 2026-10-27
Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
How this article was made: it was drafted with AI assistance from the official sources listed above, and its figures were checked against those pages on the dates shown. It is not based on personal hands-on testing.
Comments
Post a Comment