
The Meter Counts Contacts, Not Campaigns
The short answer: nearly every mainstream platform bills on contacts stored, so the invoice steps up when your list crosses a tier line. GetResponse Starter is listed at EUR 16 per month for 1,000 contacts, EUR 27 at 2,500, and EUR 48 at 5,000 as of August 2026. Sending twice as often changes none of that. Removing 300 dead subscribers can change all of it.
That single fact reframes the budget question. The lever that moves your bill is list hygiene, not campaign restraint.
Plenty of small senders discover this backwards. They cut back on emailing to save money, lose engagement, and still receive the same invoice.
Where the Tier Boundaries Actually Sit
- ● Free tiers stop at different points
- ● The first paid step is steepest
- ● Trials hide the ongoing cost
Free tiers end at wildly different places, and the gap is larger than most comparisons admit. Mailchimp caps its free plan at 250 contacts with a maximum of 500 sends per month and 250 per day. Kit advertises a free plan reaching up to 10,000 subscribers.
Those two numbers describe the same category of product and differ by a factor of forty. A list of 800 people is a paid account on one platform and a free one on the other.
The first paid step matters just as much. Mailchimp Essentials starts at 13 dollars per month and Standard at 20, both with a 14-day trial, while Premium is listed at 350 dollars per month.
AWeber takes a different shape again. Lite starts at 15 dollars per month for 500 subscribers and Plus at 30 dollars for the same 500, with no free plan and a 14-day trial instead.
Confirm current pricing on the official site before you budget. These figures move, and promotional discounts often expire after the first year.
| Platform | Free tier | First paid step | What the meter counts | Where it bites |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mailchimp | 250 contacts, 500 sends per month | Essentials from 13 dollars per month | Contacts stored | Very small free ceiling |
| Kit | Up to 10,000 subscribers | Creator at 33 dollars per month for 1,000 | Subscribers stored | Paid features start early |
| GetResponse | Trial only, 14 days | Starter at EUR 16 per month for 1,000 | Contacts stored | Steep steps above 2,500 |
| AWeber | None, 14-day trial | Lite at 15 dollars per month for 500 | Subscribers stored | Low first tier ceiling |
Three Billing Models Wearing the Same Interface
- ● Contacts stored is the usual meter
- ● Send metering suits quiet lists
- ● Feature tiers charge for automation
Contact-metered billing is the default. You pay for everyone stored in the account, whether they opened a message this year or not, and the ladder climbs in steps rather than smoothly.
Send-metered billing charges for messages delivered instead. A quiet list of 20,000 that gets one newsletter a quarter can cost less here than a busy list of 2,000 on a contact plan.
Feature-tier billing sits on top of both. Automation, landing pages, and reporting depth often decide your plan more than list size does. Kit Pro is listed at 66 dollars per month for the same 1,000 subscribers that cost 33 dollars on Creator.
Knowing which meter you are on tells you which lever works. Pruning helps on contact plans, sending less helps on send plans, and neither helps when one feature pins you to a higher tier.
The mix also decides how a bad month feels. On a contact plan, a quiet month still costs full price, so the fixed expense sits there whether you publish or not.
On a send plan the cost follows activity, which suits seasonal businesses and irregular newsletters. The tradeoff is that a successful campaign season produces a bill you did not forecast.
What Quietly Inflates the Number You Pay For
Unsubscribed people usually stay in the account. The platform keeps them so it can honour the opt-out, and on many plans they still occupy a billable slot until you archive or delete them.
Hard bounces linger the same way. An address that failed permanently six months ago is still a row in your database, still counted, and still worth nothing.
Duplicate storage catches teams by surprise. Platforms that split contacts into separate audiences or lists may count the same person once per list, so a customer who filled in two signup forms can be billed twice.
Imported cold lists are the worst offender. They add cost immediately, damage deliverability, and rarely produce the revenue that would justify either.
Form spam adds a slower leak. An unprotected signup form collects fake addresses at a steady trickle, and each one takes a paid slot until somebody notices the pattern.
How Pricing Pages Hide the Second Number
Most pricing tables default to the annual view. The figure you see is the discounted monthly equivalent, and the number you pay each month on a rolling plan sits higher, sometimes by a fifth.
Contact sliders are the second trap. A page shows an attractive price at the lowest tier, and the increase between the tier you are in and the one you will reach next quarter never appears on screen at the same time.
Overage rules deserve a direct answer before you sign. Some platforms block sending once you cross the limit, some upgrade you automatically, and the difference matters on the morning a viral post adds 900 subscribers.
Trial length tells you how much testing you get. Mailchimp and AWeber both advertise 14 days, which is enough to check deliverability and imports but not enough to judge a full campaign cycle.
Doing the Arithmetic Before the Renewal Notice
Start with the number that actually earns. Export the subscribers who opened or clicked anything in the last 90 days, then compare that count against your billed count.
If the gap runs to a few hundred people and you sit just above a tier line, the cheapest upgrade is a cleanup. Run one re-engagement campaign, give it two weeks, then remove the silent remainder.
If the gap is small and you are still above the line, the growth is real and the tier is honest. Budget for it and move on rather than trimming a list that works.
Annual billing deserves the same arithmetic. A discount around 15 to 20 percent is common, but it locks in a tier, so it pays off once your list size has been steady for a few months. The same trap shows up across subscriptions, which is why annual versus monthly SaaS billing is worth settling before the discount tempts you.
Which Pricing Shape Fits Your List
- ● Small and frequent favours flat tiers
- ● Large and quiet favours send metering
- ● Growing lists need bought headroom
Under 500 subscribers, emailing weekly: a low flat tier wins. AWeber Lite at 15 dollars per month for 500, or the Mailchimp free plan for a list under 250, covers this without automation you will not touch.
Between 1,000 and 5,000 and growing: buy headroom deliberately. GetResponse steps from EUR 16 to EUR 48 across that range, so pick the platform whose next two steps you have already read rather than the friendliest first step.
Over 10,000 but quiet: look at send-metered plans or a generous free tier. A list this size on a contact plan pays storage rent every month whether a campaign goes out or not.
Revenue tied to automation: ignore the headline price and compare feature tiers. If purchase-triggered sequences live two plans up, that is your real starting price, whatever the entry tier advertises.
Nonprofit or seasonal sender: ask about discounts and pause options before committing. Several platforms offer nonprofit rates that never appear on the public pricing page.
One person with two side projects: keep them in one account only if the platform counts contacts across the whole account rather than per audience. Otherwise two small accounts on separate free tiers can beat one paid tier.
What the Cost Per Subscriber Actually Tells You
Divide the monthly bill by active subscribers and you get a number worth tracking. At EUR 16 for 1,000 contacts, a fully engaged list costs under two cents per person per month.
That figure only means something next to revenue. A list where one in fifty people buys a 40 dollar product each quarter earns far more than it costs, and a list with no offer at all earns nothing at any price.
Track the ratio rather than the invoice. A rising bill on a list that converts is a good problem, while a flat bill on a list nobody reads is money leaving quietly every month.
The same test settles the upgrade question. If the higher tier unlocks a feature you can tie to revenue, the price step pays for itself.
If it does not, the cheaper tier is the right answer, whatever the comparison chart implies.
The Switch That Costs More Than the Subscription
Moving platforms to save 10 dollars a month is usually a bad trade. You rebuild automations, re-create forms, and lose the engagement history that segmentation depends on.
Deliverability carries the real risk. A new sending reputation needs warming, and a large first send from an unfamiliar platform can land in spam folders that used to receive you fine. Authentication records need redoing too, which puts SPF, DKIM, and DMARC on the migration checklist rather than the wish list.
Switch when the platform blocks something you need, not when a competitor advertises a cheaper entry tier. If price alone is the trigger, read how to switch email marketing platforms without losing subscribers first and price the disruption honestly.
One related question is worth settling before any of this. Whether a tool earns its keep is a different test from whether it is cheap, and is Constant Contact worth it for a small business works through that shape of decision.
What to Check Before You Approve the Renewal
Pull three numbers: contacts billed, contacts active in 90 days, and the subscriber count at the next tier line. Those three tell you whether the coming increase reflects growth or neglect.
Then decide once. Prune and stay, or accept the tier and stop worrying, because the worst outcome is paying for a larger list while emailing it less out of guilt.
Pricing pages change quarterly and promotional rates expire. Confirm current pricing on the official site, such as the Mailchimp pricing page, before the renewal date, and put that date in a calendar rather than trusting a reminder email.
FAQ
Why did my email marketing bill go up when I did not send more emails?
Almost every mainstream platform bills on contacts stored, not messages delivered. Crossing a tier line by a single subscriber moves you to the next price step, even if you sent one campaign that month. Check which number your plan meters before blaming campaign volume.
Do unsubscribed contacts still count toward my plan limit?
On contact-metered plans they usually do until you delete or archive them. Unsubscribed people stay in the account so the platform can honour the opt-out, and many billing counters still include them. Look for an archive or cleaned-contact option that removes them from the billable count.
Is annual billing worth it for email marketing software?
Annual billing is cheaper per month on most platforms, and the discount often lands around 15 to 20 percent. The catch is that it locks in a tier you might outgrow or shrink out of within the year. Pay annually once your list size has been stable for a few months.
Should I delete inactive subscribers to stay under a pricing tier?
Yes, when the inactive segment is large enough to push you over a tier line. Subscribers who have opened nothing in six to twelve months rarely convert, and they drag open rates down as well as costs up. Run a re-engagement campaign first, then remove whoever stays silent.
Can a free plan handle a list of 1,000 subscribers?
It depends on the platform, since free tiers differ enormously. Mailchimp caps its free plan at 250 contacts, while Kit advertises a free plan up to 10,000 subscribers with a narrower feature set. A list of 1,000 fits comfortably in one and not at all in the other.
Sources
- Email sender guidelines - Gmail Help — checked 2026-10-01
- Mailchimp Pricing Plans | Get Started Today — checked 2026-10-01
Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
How this article was made: it was drafted with AI assistance from the official sources listed above, and its figures were checked against those pages on the dates shown. It is not based on personal hands-on testing.
Comments
Post a Comment